Table of contents

angle-down

    Most marketers are using AI.

    Some estimates put adoption at over 80%. The tools are embedded in workflows, baked into platforms, and increasingly expected as part of the role. The question, then, is no longer whether to use AI.

    It’s whether you can tell when it’s wrong.

    This is the distinction many professionals miss. Adoption and fluency are different capabilities. As AI lowers the barrier to execution, another capability is becoming far more valuable – and far more scarce: judgment. 

    In an LSE Digital Marketing Career Accelerator panel webinar, The Future of AI – But What Does That Mean For Marketing, panellists discussed this very topic. 

    As Sian Heaphy, Senior Marketing Director at Bright, put it:

    “What will leave people behind is if they can’t take it beyond tooling and think about the problems, think about the systems within which we’re talking…but also not being afraid to challenge what AI is generating or telling us.”

    The implication is clear. In an AI-saturated landscape, tool use is expected. The ability to interrogate outputs sets marketers apart.

    When convincing isn’t correct

    One of the more revealing moments in the discussion came from Fernanda Aventurato, a Product Marketing and Partnerships professional at Birlasoft, and a graduate of the LSE Digital Marketing Career Accelerator.

    She described a recent campaign misstep by a global brand.

    Nike had launched a Brazil national team shirt ahead of a major tournament. The design was strong, the branding consistent. But a small detail – the phrase “Go Brasa” printed inside the shirt – triggered immediate backlash.

    The problem? No one in Brazil actually uses the term.

    “No one in Brazil uses ‘Brasa’… this shows a complete lack of real cultural understanding of the country.”

    What was likely derived from secondary research – potentially even AI-assisted – failed a simple test: cultural truth. The result wasn’t just a minor error, but a signal of a disconnect between brand and audience.

    As Fernanda explained:

    “Critical thinking, context, real human understanding are extremely important. Without this, it can easily go to the wrong direction.”

    This is the risk of AI-generated outputs. They are often fluent, coherent and persuasive. But they are not inherently correct.

    What the research actually shows

    A study cited during the webinar – conducted by Penn State and the University of Connecticut, involving more than 450 participants – found that half of an individual’s creative performance when using AI comes from what they already bring to the table.

    As Fernanda shared:

    “Half of a person’s creative performance with AI comes from what they already bring to the table… intelligence, previous creativity and critical thinking.”

    In other words, AI does not replace these capabilities. It amplifies them – or exposes their absence.

    She added a further distinction:

    “Being good at creating with AI… it’s a separate skill. It’s not the same as being naturally creative or simply intelligent. Learning to think and collaborate together without letting the tool take over – this is the key.”

    The most valuable AI skill is, in fact, judgment under uncertainty: the ability to assess outputs, challenge assumptions, and apply context. 

    The employer lens: judgment over output

    This shift is already visible in how marketing talent is being evaluated.

    As AI becomes more capable of generating strategies, content and analysis, the traditional markers of competence are becoming less meaningful. If a tool can produce a campaign plan in seconds, asking a candidate to “create a strategy” reveals very little.

    Sian suggests a different approach:

    “A better task might be: here are five things – how are you going to prioritise them? What criteria are you using? What data are you using to assess?”

    The emphasis moves from output to reasoning.

    From:

    • What can you produce?

    To:

    • How do you think?
    • How do you decide?
    • How do you challenge what you’re given?

    She also emphasised that while tools matter, they are not the differentiator:

    “Yes, tooling and that knowledge is very important, but actually what will leave people behind is if they can’t take it beyond tooling.”

    Fernanda’s own progression reflects this shift from execution to strategic thinking.

    Her turning point came during the Career Accelerator’s Employer Project, a real-world challenge that pushed her beyond task execution into structured decision-making.

    As she describes:

    “I saw myself knowing which framework to use. When I saw the whole strategy aligned, grounded in the data and the research aligned, I realised, okay, I’m not just trying to keep up anymore. I’m actually being part of all this.”

    That shift – from applying tools to shaping strategy – reflects a broader capability gap: the ability to apply AI in ways that drive meaningful outcomes. As execution becomes easier, judgment becomes the signal employers look for. 

    Building the skill: what it actually takes

    If judgment is the differentiator, the next question is how to develop it.

    It starts with strong foundations. 

    Sian emphasised this, saying:

    “I think having solid foundations is more important… and then what you need to build on is actually more of those softer skills.”

    Without these, AI outputs remain unanchored – persuasive, but unreliable.

    There is also a progression in how marketers engage with AI:

    From execution to analysis to leadership.

    As Sian described:

    “If you’re in that create and execute phase, you’re probably thinking more about how do I use this tool… whereas as you move up, it becomes much more about where does this materially change how we compete.”

    Fernanda offered a practical example from her own work. After conducting interviews with senior stakeholders, she used AI not just to summarise, but to uncover hidden signals:

    “Even in a room full of positive feedback, AI could give me some small moments of hesitation… that, if ignored, could grow and become issues in the future.”

    The value came from interpretation – how the insight was understood and applied. 

    Fluency is a judgment call

    As AI continues to evolve, the gap between those who use it and those who use it well will widen.

    Some will use AI to work faster. Others will use it to shape strategy and drive real impact.

    The difference lies in how AI is applied – through reasoning, context and critical thinking in environments where outputs are abundant, but clarity is limited. 

    As Sian put it:

    “Self-awareness is the best starting point. If you’re aware of it, you can fix it.” 

    For marketers navigating this shift, the priority is developing the capability to question AI – to assess what it produces, understand its limitations, and apply it with intent. 

    Structured, applied learning environments – including programmes such as the LSE Digital Marketing Strategy & Analytics Career Accelerator, which holds Employability Programme status from the Chartered Institute of Marketing – are increasingly designed with this in mind. Not to teach tools in isolation, but to build the judgment required to use them effectively.

    As the barrier to execution continues to fall, one capability is becoming the profession’s most durable competitive advantage: the ability to think.